The Phoenix Theatre is all about the out-of-the-box plays, and their newest one highlights history in an unconventional yet meditative way. “Butler” will be on stage at the Phoenix, 749 N. Park Ave., now through Feb. 7. Regular ticket prices are $27–$33.
It’s the beginning of the Civil War, and lawyer Benjamin Franklin Butler has just been promoted to Union General at Fort Monroe. He soon finds himself face to face with Shepard Mallory, an escaped slave seeking asylum at the fort for himself and other slaves. Sworn to uphold the law, Butler prepares to return the slaves, until Mallory forces him to question whether what is legal is actually right.
The Recorder sat down with Ramon Hutchins, who plays Shepard Mallory in “Butler,” to get his perspective on this play, which was inspired by real events, and how the theme is relevant to the Black Lives Matter movement of today.
Indianapolis Recorder Newspaper: Slavery is an important topic in American history, but in today’s racially tense climate, it can be tough. Was this play difficult for you?
Hutchins: Initially it was. I was happy to be a part of the Phoenix Theatre, but my personal feelings were certainly there. They don’t want to make slavery a laughing matter, but after reading the script and understanding the perspective that’s being presented, I didn’t feel it was inappropriate.
How does this play relate to racial tension happening in America today?
With everything going on and how the media has brought things forward, it has awakened the awkwardness between Blacks and whites. Not that we hate each other, but in the sense that things that have taken place has caused people to have to face certain subjects. You see that in the play too.
Are there elements in the play you believe will enlighten or educate audiences?
For me, this play was a great revelation. For African-Americans who come see the play, naturally they’re going to understand Shepard. He was committed no matter what. Nothing in his situation screamed in his favor, yet he pursued his goal with death being almost guaranteed. I think audiences can learn from him.
Tell us more about Shepard Mallory.
Shepard Mallory is an aware, witty, not-so-careful person. He’s resilient and can shift at a moment’s notice. But that’s because he’s willing to risk everything to get to his little piece of happiness. And for him that’s not much. The injustice he feels, he just can’t take. So he sets out to really figure out what his happiness is.
This theater is very intimate. How does the closeness of the audience add to this play?
This play is very wordy. A lot of things that happen are taken at face value. I can’t just say, “I’m ready to return to my cell.” You can see and feel the tension in this intimate setting. This setting drives home the point of this play.
Indianapolis has a blossoming theater scene. Why should audiences support the Phoenix and see this play?
First it’s the Phoenix. If you want to think, see this play. It’s history that people won’t expect. Other than that, it’s a funny show. It’s a great show. It’s only four of us, but there’s great talent on this stage.
