My first taste of Amazing Joe’s happened during my days at Ball State University. I first heard about the restaurant during an English class. One of my class members mentioned she worked there and recommended I try the food one day. That summer, I dragged my roommate to Amazing Joe’s, and the rest is history. Not only was their food great, they also had great drinks and service.
When I saw the “Amazing Joe’s” sign being hammered to the outside of a building at Clearwater Crossing on East 82nd Street, my smile grew from ear to ear. I instantly remembered the great flavors of Amazing Joe’s and knew I had to stop by. I decided to bring one of my good friends, Mia, along for the journey to great food.
Let me start off by saying how friendly the staff was. Before we ordered, we were greeted by Chad Massoth, managing partner of Amazing Joe’s, who said although the location had only been open for a couple of weeks, business was going very well. We also chatted about a few recommended menu items. I did notice a menu with specials resting on the table. Every Monday through Thursday from 4–5 p.m., customers can enjoy dishes such as USDA Choice hand-cut sirloin, chicken fingers, pork chops, a variety of salads, catfish and more for just $9.99. Also, 18-ounce margaritas are $4.49 all day every Sunday.
What I remember most about Amazing Joe’s in Muncie is the chicken wings. While they were tempting, I decided on something different. I ordered the Grilled Shrimp Dinner, which included seasoned and grilled shrimp with garlic butter served on a bed of rice. For my two sides I chose a house salad and steamed broccoli. Mia ordered the Marinated Chicken Kabob Chicken, with red and green peppers, red onions and zucchini all marinated in a special house sauce. The large menu also offers items such as the Blackened Salmon Caesar Salad, Italian Chicken Nachos, Ribeye Steak, Joe’s “Famous Filet” Kabob, N’awlins Pasta Bowl, Cheesy Chicken Mac, ribs and more.
Once we ordered, Massoth returned to let us know about some of the community activities Amazing Joe’s has completed. Those who wore a full Santa suit on Christmas received a free meal, and for those not interested in playing dress up, a small bag of non-perishable items or winter coats could be traded in for a full entree at Amazing Joe’s. I thought this was a great way to connect with the community. About 15 minutes later, Mia and I found our conversation perished as our attention was solely focused on the food. My grilled shrimp was very well seasoned and Mia’s chicken kabob looked fantastic. You could tell it came straight off of the grill and on to the plate.
Next time, I’m looking to try the Cheesy Chicken Mac or the chicken wings … maybe even a margarita as well.
Amazing Joe’s Steakhouse
3716 E. 82nd St.
Indianapolis, IN 46240
(317) 436-7367
Monday–Friday:
4–11 p.m.
Saturday–Sunday:
11 a.m.–11 p.m.
