29.2 F
Monday, January 18, 2021

IU expert: H1N1 public health messages inform rather than scare

More by this author

Debutantes evolving excellently

The Alpha Mu Omega Chapter of Alpha Kappa Alpha Sorority Inc. and Ivy Endowment Inc. 34th annual Debutante Cotillion and Scholarship Ball, “Harlem Renaissance:...

Transcript: Mayor Pete Buttigieg at Greater Indianapolis NAACP Freedom Fund Banquet

South Bend mayor and Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg spoke at the Greater Indianapolis NAACP Freedom Fund Banquet on Oct. 4. Below is a...

Harrison-Jones delivers keynote speech at MLK event

Crispus Attucks High School rescheduled the Dr. Martin Luther King Junior program to last Friday. The Rev. Winterbourne LaPucelle Harrison-Jones, author and fifth-generation minister,...

Restaurant workers live below the poverty level

One of the largest labor sectors in the U.S., the restaurant industry, has nearly half of its workers living under the income threshold required...

BLOOMINGTON, Ind. – So far, the communication strategies being employed by health care officials to warn people about the dangers of the 2009 H1N1 virus and needed precautions have been effective, said Carolyn Calloway-Thomas, an Indiana University professor and an expert on rhetoric.

Rather than use strong, fear-arousing messages, the national Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the National Institutes of Health and other agencies have struck a necessary balance that also has included sensible arguments about prevention.

“There is evidence that the use of intense, fear-arousing appeals to persuade people who are already scared is often ineffective,” said Calloway-Thomas, an associate professor in the Department of Communication and Culture in the College of Arts and Sciences. “Studies also suggest that people change their unhealthy behavior when fear arousing appeals are accompanied by sensible, argument-based processing of general information.

“The messages that I have seen with regard to H1N1 have been balanced. I have not observed any high anxiety producing messages that are designed to make people feel dreadful,” she added.

In recent weeks, there have been reports that the government has not had enough time to create enough batches of vaccines and that some of the previous vaccines used had been contaminated.

“There are some fear elements that are poisoning the environment right now, but I don’t think they are potent enough to disturb the messages that are circulating about why it’s important for us to get the H1N1 vaccine,” she said.

Calloway-Thomas, who currently is working on a study on decision making by women of color about the need for mammograms, also praised the focus being placed on other prevention methods, including thorough hand-washing.

“There has been a nice balance between the threat level and the messages that are accompanying the threat,” she said.

“Generally, messages in health care education campaigns are designed to change the negative habits of individuals toward more positive ones,”

Calloway-Thomas said. “The overall purpose of such campaigns is to persuade people to cease unhealthy behaviors.”

Examples of failed tactics have included various anti-smoking and the

“This Is Your Brain on Drugs” campaigns.

“The bottom line is that organizations should be very careful when creating persuasive messages in a high threat environment. Evoking extreme fear is ill-advised.”

- Advertisement -

Upcoming Online Townhalls

- Advertisement -

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest local news.

Stay connected


Related articles

Popular articles

It’s on you, white America

The insurrection at the Capitol is as American as apple pie. I know many in white America have a...

Our Future is Powerful Voices

This program is closing the opportunity gap for black and brown students. Find out how you can participate.

Amid the pandemic, more Black families on the brink of homelessness

Three times a week, an Uber ride on Indianapolis’ east side helps to save the life of bright-eyed, 11-year-old Jay’Shawn Roberson.

Too many are dying

Black Indianapolis has to rediscover a culture of life. Last year we lost 158 Black people to criminal homicides...

Ethics and professionalism in the workplace

If you look up the word ethics in the dictionary, you’ll find this definition: “rules of behavior based on ideas about what is morally...
Español + Translate »
Skip to content